Sunday, December 14, 2008

An FB encounter

No, I'm not talking about that FB. I've been using Facebook for a while now, and one particular phenomenon that never ceases to amaze and puzzle me is getting a friend request from a total stranger with no preliminaries and no context whatsoever. I'll admit that I have sent friend requests to Facebook people I haven't met in real life, or those who are friends of a friend, or someone who I thought was attractive. I also have a friend who once so often recommends someone - whom I've never met - as a friend, and since I personally know him and trust him, I don't mind such requests, as I'm not totally opposed to the idea of serendipitous friendships. Or a romantic relationship. After all, my current friends were strangers to me at one time. But in each instance, there was a conversation about a shared common interest, a few interactions or flirtatious exchanges, a meeting in the real world, or a mention of the said common friend that preceded sending a request to befriend them or acknowledging one from them. By the way, I'm defining a conversation as a message sent and a response received which shows some mutual interest. I still have to cross the Rubicon of sending a friend request to a total stranger on FB with no prior interaction whatsoever.

Such random out-of-the-blue requests make me wonder and some questions pop into my mind. Is this person only interested in increasing the number of friends on FB? Is he thinking of having a conversation with me about some shared interest(s)? Is she simply content to be a virtual friend with no desire to meet in real life? (I've got random requests from both men and women.) Maybe their idea of a "friend" and what form a friendship takes is vastly different from mine, as I didn't grow up permanently plugged into a digital device and with one foot in the virtual world. Are they feeling lonely, and Facebook provides a safe medium where a "rejection" doesn't hurt to the extent it would in real life, and an acceptance of a friend request provides a momentary high and a validation? Or are they just so high on life and full of love and light that they exhibit warm and fuzzy feelings of friendship for all beings, resulting in requests sent to total strangers? More importantly, does she have a crush on me?

Call me old-fashioned, and while I do have some wonderful internet friendships with people I haven't met in person yet, I prefer to meet people in real life and have friendships that develop beyond just streaming bits of 0s and 1s. The idea of sending someone a friend request on FB as the first step - and that too without any accompanying personal message - just comes across as too bizzare to me and raises a red flag. If someone is incapable of writing even a line or two telling me why the request was sent, that just doesn't bode well for our "friendship." It shows the dichotomy where Americans display an obsession with privacy and resist any measures they consider intrusive, yet think nothing of sending a friend request to a stranger on the internet which would give that stranger access to their personal information.

Here's the back-and-forth that prompted this post:

"Joe (not his true name) added you as a friend on Facebook."

Me: "Have we met? I don't remember meeting you."

Pithy Joe: "friend of terence."

I used to work with someone whose first name was Terrence, so I thought maybe we'd been introduced by Terry sometime. Still, I wanted to confirm.

Me: "Terence who?"

Hyper-excited Joe: "McKenna!!!!!!!!!!!" (with some 50+ exclamation points, I kid you not.)

Um. OK. Since I was unfamiliar with the name, I looked up Terence McKenna on the web to find out what exactly was his claim to fame that would get someone so excited.

Me: "I didn't know that Terence McKenna existed before you mentioned him. I'm not sure why you'd think I'm his friend."

Fruitcake Joe: "You can ignore our friend request. Perhaps we're better enemies than friends."

What? Come again???

Clearly in my attempt to have a conversation, I offended Joe. It's good to know that a friend of Terence McKenna views others as either friends or enemies, with no neutral third option available. Too bad that Joe didn't display his coherent and complete sentence construction skills earlier - I just might have approved his friend request if we'd started off with a pleasant and meaningful exchange.

Moreover, netiquette in instances like these remains fuzzy. Maybe the nice option is to simply accept all friend requests without a second thought so as to not upset anyone - and then silently de-friend the undesirables a week later. I sincerely hope it doesn't come down to it that asking a stranger some questions before deciding on their friend request is considered rude. I wonder what netiquette do others employ for similar Facebook interactions?

I'm still waiting to be poked on Facebook by a beautiful stranger though.
-

9 comments:

Sarah said...

That's so weird! Maybe they confused you with another Amit?

I've gotten lots of friend requests from strangers who have some tangential interest-- they're a member of some socialist group in another country, that sort of thing. And occasional from readers of my blog, but that's not a total stranger. That sort of thing seems to happen more frequently on MySpace, which is more public, but I find it strange on FB.

(BTW I'd add you if I knew your last name! You can find me as sarah dot e dot grey at gmail dot com.)

Good to see you posting! I should do that sometime...

Amit said...

Sarah: It's possible that they mistook me for another Amit, though with my last name, that becomes less probable. Besides, I've never gotten a note with the friend request that says, "Hey, I know you from so-and-so" which I find even weirder.

My hypothesis is that the internet makes many actions possible which would be frowned upon and considered rude in the real world.

"Good to see you posting! I should do that sometime..."

Yeah, I noticed that you haven't updated your blog either. Maybe answering a tag would help jump-start it? :)

Nita said...

Your thinking is very rational Amit. In fact I had an account on Orkut (beofe FB became the big thing) and I deleted it precisely for this reason. Unknown requests for friendships which I do not look upon kindly. In fact I simply asked my daughters who are veterans e-connectors and their advise is always ignore a friend request from an unknown. Do not engage them in the why's as they are probably just fruitcakes anyway, or could have some ulterior motive, or simply wants a lot of names as "friends". Whatever their reason, the thing is to ignore them. In any case I had not time to even ignore such people and simply deleted my account! :)
You are absolutely right, one needs to have some sort of communication before accepting a person even as an internet friend. In any case, nowadays I only have linkedin, which I joined recently. No facebooks for me.
And through blogging I have met such nice people, infact have developed a whole network of e-friends!

ZenDenizen said...

If I don't recognize someone right away but we do have mutual friends on FB, I accept and assume we've met at some point somewhere thru that mutual friend. If I don't recognize them at all, I just hit ignore because they don't get a notification that they've been ignored or anything.

Amit said...

Nita: Not engaging strangers is probably the best policy. I wonder whether Facebook will go the Friendster way in near future.

Zen: I like your rule-of-thumb for friend requests on Facebook, and I'll adopt it too.

Shefaly said...

Amit

Many discussions of this kind have been going on for a while. Manuscrypts has a recent post which may interest you while ConfusedOfCalcutta did a post on politeness in these situations. Both are interesting reads. My own FB rule is that it is strictly family and friends who may know secrets they can damage me with ;-) New contacts on FB are likely those whom I have met in person and with whom I have a long 'relationship' otherwise and whom I know well (e.g. values, preferences etc). On LinkedIn, I am a total purist - if I have not attended school or worked with (as client, consultant, co-worker in a non-profit, another capacity such as being a 'source' for a journalist for a while) someone, I am not able to vouch for them professionally so I beg off.

And on rejection: what are you saying, Sir? It hurts some every bit on the web as it does in real life. I just keep quiet on such invitations.

Amit said...

Shefaly: Thanks. Re: online rejection, I didn't say it doesn't hurt, but definitely it's not as hurtful as one in a real-life interaction, relatively speaking of course.

Ashish Gupta said...

I always ignore random requests since those who don't even bother to introduce themselves aren't worth pursuing or interesting to me. And I've had exchanges where someone "views others as either friends or enemies, with no neutral third option available". I am kind of selective in who I accept because if I just accept too many, whole point becomes useless as my friends' list become cluttered and finding real friend itself become difficult.

Amit said...

Ashish: Welcome, and thanks for sharing your perspective. One of the issues is the uncertainty and grey areas regarding the functionality of FB and what a user wants out of it. This only gets clearer after a person has used the application for a while and then done some sort of review based on experience.

Post a Comment

This is a personal blog, and I will likely delete any comments that I find discourteous, inappropriate or off-topic.

Instead of posting anonymously, please consider using a handle or pseudonym, as that makes it easier to respond. Thanks.